Go to the page with the accessible poll table.

Forgot password? · Create account

Poll: Street Repair Informal Poll

Summary: 5 participants,
2 comments, 0 files
more …
 supports Doodle as a Premium Member.
Learn more …
Michael Griffith has created this poll.

"Help the HOA board select a plan for our street repairs. This is a non-binding poll which will help us decide which plan to put to a vote in the community.

Each company's proposals are ordered from least cost to greatest cost. For example, Industrial Pavement's plan for $4972.60 is marked as Plan A, their $5772.54 is Plan B and their $29,187 proposal is Plan C in the poll."

Siskin
Alison McLaughlin
Ruth Gayle Ehlers
sakali
Daming Liu
Count
Industrial Pavement Maintenance Plan A Industrial Pavement Maintenance Plan B Industrial Pavement Maintenance Plan C A & S Paving Plan A A & S Paving Plan B Sunland Asphalt A Sunland Asphalt B K & B Asphalt A K & B Asphalt B
    (OK) OK OK (OK)      
  OK              
  (OK) OK   OK       (OK)
    (OK)   OK        
  OK              
0
0
5
2
1
2
1
2
2
1
0
4
3
0
2
0
1
4
0
0
5
0
0
5
0
1
4

green = in favor
yellow = could live with this option
red = against

Functions

Comments (2)

Add a comment >>

  • Chris Munson
    March 2, 2009
    1:34:25 PM PST

    What kind of warranty / life expectancy comes with the IP, Sunland and K&B options?

  • Siskin
    February 26, 2009
    10:42:25 PM PST

    In my opinion A&S quotes are not significantly different in dollars so it makes sense to get the extra years by spending the extra cost to get their plan B.
    If I had to choose between a fabric overlay and either IPM's plan C, Sunlands plan A, or K&B's plan A, I'd need to know how long they expect these plans to "last". The extra cost again to get a fabric overlay is in my opinion worth it vs. the less expensive options.